
MPPOL
Introduction
Materials & Methods
Results
Discussion
References
|
Molecular Plant Pathology On-line [http://www.bspp.org.uk/mppol/]
1997/0624karan
Association of Banana Bunchy Top Virus DNA Components 2 to 6 with Bunchy
Top Disease.
Mirko Karan1 , Robert M Harding, James L Dale*
Centre for Molecular Biotechnology, School of Life Sciences, Queensland University of
Technology, GPO Box 2434, Brisbane 4001, Queensland, Australia.
Current address: 1 Biochemistry Department, School of Molecular Sciences, James
Cook University of North Queensland, Townsville 4811, Queensland, Australia.
Fax: +61 77 251 294, Email: Mirko.Karan@jcu.edu.au

|

INTRODUCTION
|


Banana bunchy top virus (BBTV) is the most economically important virus infecting
bananas (Dale, 1987). The virus is transmitted
persistently by the aphid Pentalonia
nigronervosa but does not appear to replicate in its vector (Hafner et al., 1995), is not
mechanically transmissible and is apparently phloem limited. BBTV has only recently
been isolated and characterised (Wu and Su, 1990;
Harding et al., 1991). The virus
has
isometric virions 18-20 nm in diameter and a genome that consists of multiple circular
single-stranded DNA components each about 1.1 kb. A single protein of 19.6 kDa is
associated with the virions and is assumed to be the coat protein (Harding et al., 1991;
Burns et al., 1994). A number of BBTV ssDNA components have been identified
and
sequenced. Harding et al.(1993) reported
the sequence of BBTV DNA component 1
(BBTV DNA-1) from an Australian isolate of BBTV. This component is 1.1kb and
contains one large open reading frame (ORF) in the virion sense. This ORF encodes a
putative replication protein (Rep) based on the presence of the dNTP binding
motif GGEGKT. Associated with this ORF are a potential TATA box and
polyadenylation signals. BBTV DNA-1 also contains a sequence capable of forming a
stable stem-loop structure; 9 nucleotides of the loop sequence are very
similar to the highly conserved nonanucleotide loop sequence present in geminivirus
stem-loop structures (Lazarowitz, 1992).
Yeh et al. (1994) and Wu et al. (1994)
have
reported the sequences of three additional components from Taiwanese BBTV isolates.
These three components have a similar structure to BBTV DNA-1 in that each contains
a sequence capable of forming a stable stem-loop structure and includes the highly
conserved nonanucleotide loop sequence and the two components of Wu et al. (1994)
each contained one large ORF which encode putative Reps. These Reps are different
to each other and different to that encoded by BBTV DNA-1. The component of
Yeh et al. (1994) could potentially encode a
putative
Rep if the sequence is slightly altered and
this potential Rep would be different to that encoded by BBTV DNA-1 and almost
identical to that for DNA-1 of Wu et al. (1994).
Burns et al. (1995) have recently reported
the sequence and structure of five BBTV
components called BBTV DNA-2, 3, 4, 5 and 6; none of these components encode
Reps. Each component has a structure similar to that of BBTV DNA-1 in that each
component has one large ORF in the virion sense (except for BBTV DNA-2) with an
associated potential TATA box and polyadenylation signal(s) and a sequence 5' of the
ORF capable of forming a stable stem-loop structure; the loop sequence in each
component contains the highly conserved nonanucleotide sequence. Further,
Burns et al. (1995)
identified two regions that are highly
conserved between all six components
(BBTV DNA-1 to 6) identified from Australian BBTV isolates. The stem-loop common
region (CR-SL) extends up to 25 nucleotides 5' of the stem-loop sequence and up to 13
nucleotides 3' of the stem-loop sequence. The major common region (CR-M) is located
5' of the CR-SL and is between 65 and 92 nucleotides in length. The functions of the
putative proteins encoded by the large virion sense ORFs in BBTV DNA-3, 4, 5 and 6
have not been determined.
A further four BBTV-like viruses have been identified. All these viruses have isometric
virions about 20 nm in diameter, genomes of ssDNA about 1 kb and three of them are
persistently transmitted by aphids. These four viruses, together with BBTV, are
probably members of a new plant virus group. Boevink et al. (1995) have identified and
sequenced seven ssDNA components of subterranean clover stunt virus (SCSV). All
have one large ORF in the virion sense, a sequence 5' of the ORF capable of forming a
stable stem-loop structure and the loop sequence includes the highly conserved
nonanucleotide sequence. Five of the components share a conserved common region.
SCSV-5 has been shown to encode the SCSV coat protein (Chu et al., 1993; Boevink
et al., 1995) and two components encode putative Reps. Interestingly, the two Rep
encoding components do not contain the common region. One component has been
identified and sequenced from coconut foliar decay virus (CFDV) (Rohde et al., 1990)
and faba bean necrotic yellows virus (FBNYV) (Katul
et al., 1995). Both these
components have a similar structure to the components of BBTV and SCSV with one
large ORF 3' of a stem-loop sequence. Both these components encode putative Reps.
No sequence information is available for milk vetch dwarf virus (MVDV) (Sano et al.,
1993).
None of the BBTV-like viruses have been shown to be infectious even though
Chu et al.(1993) demonstrated that SCSV can
replicate in pea
protoplasts. Therefore, it is not
known which components constitute the essential genome of these viruses and
whether, particularly for BBTV and SCSV, all components have been identified and
whether these viruses require more than one Rep to replicate.
Recently, we demonstrated that BBTV DNA-1 is associated with all BBTV isolates
tested from ten countries (Karan et al., 1994).
This provides some evidence that BBTV
DNA-1 is an integral component of the BBTV genome. Interestingly, when the
sequences of BBTV DNA-1 from the different isolates were compared, it was evident
that there are two distinct groups of isolates, the South Pacific group (isolates from
Australia, Burundi, Egypt, Fiji, India, Tonga and Western Samoa) and the Asian group
(isolates from the Philippines, Taiwan and Vietnam). Previously, BBTV DNA-2 and 5
had only been identified in Australian and Hawaiin isolates, BBTV DNA-3, 4 and 6 in
Australian isolates and the Rep encoding components of Yeh et al. (1994) and
Wu et al. (1994) in Taiwanese isolates. In this
paper,
we report the consistent association of
BBTV DNA-2, 3, 4, 5 and 6 with BBTV isolates from eight countries and further
evidence for two distinct groups or strains of BBTV isolates.

|

MATERIALS AND METHODS
|


Origin of isolates and extraction of total nucleic acid

The BBTV isolates used in this study were from Australia, Burundi, Fiji, India, Western
Samoa, the Philippines, Taiwan and Vietnam and were the same isolates used by
Karan et al. (1994). Total nucleic acid was
extracted from these samples as described
by Karan et al. (1994).
Detection of BBTV components by Southern hybridisation

Total nucleic acid extracts from BBTD isolates (10 or 20 ml) were electrophoresed in 1
% agarose gels and blotted onto Hybond-N+ (Amersham) using positive pressure
(Posiblot; Stratagene). Random priming labelling kits (Ready-To-Go; Pharmacia or
'OLK-C, oligo-labelling kit'; Bresatec) were used to prepare 32P-labelled probes.
Membranes were prehybridised in Rapid-hybe (Amersham) for 1 h at 65°C .
Membranes
were then hybridised for 16 h at 65°C in Rapid-hybe (Amersham). The membranes
were washed twice for 10 min with 2 x SSC, 0.5 % SDS, followed by two 10 min
washes in 1 x SSC, 0.1% SDS, two 10 min washes in 0.1 x SSC, 0.1 % SDS all at
65°C and a 5 min wash in 0.1 x SSC at room temperature. The membranes were
then
exposed to Agfa Curix RP1 film at -80°C using intensifying screens.
Amplification of BBTV component sequences

Oligonucleotide primers for PCR were derived from the published sequences of BBTV
DNA-2, 3, 4, 5 and 6 (Burns et al., 1995) (Table 1). All PCR reactions (50
µl) were heated
to 94°C for 4 min; then subjected to 30 cycles of 94°C for 45 s,
50°C for 45 s, and
72°C for 1 min; and finally 1 cycle of 72°C for 10 min.
Restriction enzyme analysis of PCR products

PCR products in 40 µl aliquots were purified on columns (Wizard PCR Preps; Promega)
and eluted in water (25 µl). Purified PCR product (10 µl) was digested with
Rsa I (10 U;
Gibco BRL) in final volumes of 15 µl at 37°C for 1.5 h. A 7.5 µl
aliquot of each digest
was electrophoresed in a 2 % agarose gel and stained with ethidium bromide. DNA
fragment sizes were estimated by comparison with a ØX174 DNA - Hae III digest
marker.
Cloning and sequencing of BBTV DNA-6

Full-length PCR products of BBTV DNA-6 were cloned into the T-tailed vector pGEM-T
(Promega). Cloned DNA was sequenced using [35S]dATP and a Sequenase kit (US
Biochemical) as recommended by the manufacturer. Reaction products were analysed
by electrophoresis in a 6% (w/v) polyacrylamide gel containing 7 M urea. Gels were
fixed, dried and exposed to Agfa Curix RP1 film. The primers used for sequencing were
either universal sequencing primers (US Biochemical) or 17 to 30 nucleotide primers
complementary to appropriate regions of the cloned DNA.
Computer analysis

The computer programs used for sequence analysis were accessed from the Australian
National Genomic Information Service (ANGIS), University of Sydney. CLUSTAL V
(Higgins et al., 1992) was used to align
nucleotide and amino acid sequences and to
construct Neighbor-Joining trees. The Wisconsin Genetics Computer Group (GCG)
package of programs version 7.3 (Devereux et al.,
1984) was used to translate
nucleotide sequences (TRANSLATE) and to create similarity matrices (DISTANCES).
Trees were drawn using the DRAWTREE program (PHYLIP package version 3.5c;
Felstenstein, 1993).

|

 Figure 1
 Figure 2
|

BBTV DNA-2 and 3

A number of component specific primer pairs were tested in attempts to amplify either
BBTV DNA-2 or 3. No primer pairs were identified that would amplify all or part of either
BBTV DNA-2 or 3 from all isolates. For instance, primers BT80-F1 and BT80-R3
amplified the expected BBTV DNA-2 product from the Australian, Fijian and Western
Samoan isolates but not from the Philippines, Taiwanese or Vietnamese isolates and
primers BT3V1-EXP and BT3C1-EXP amplified the expected BBTV DNA-3 product
from the Australian and Indian isolates but not from the Philippines, Taiwanese or
Vietnamese isolates. Therefore, two component specific DNA probes were designed
and generated from cloned BBTV DNA-2 and 3 of the Australian isolate (S. Prasad, R.
Harding and J. Dale, unpublished results; Burns
et al., 1995). The BBTV DNA-2 specific
probe corresponded to nucleotides 266-574 and hybridised with cloned BBTV DNA-2
but not with cloned BBTV DNA-1, 3, 4 ,5 and 6 whereas the BBTV DNA-3 specific
probe corresponded to nucleotides 213-737 and hybridised with cloned BBTV DNA-3
but not with cloned BBTV DNA-1, 2, 4, 5 and 6. These two probes used separately,
hybridised in Southern blots with nucleic acid extracts from all BBTV isolates tested but
not with extracts from healthy bananas (Figure 1
and 2). Again, the intensity of
hybridisation varied between extracts and the probe hybridised with bands of different
sizes.

|

|

BBTV DNA-4 and 5

The primer pair BT4V3.17 and BT4C2.17 amplified the expected 350bp product from
nucleic acid extracts of all isolates tested but did not amplify a product from healthy
banana extracts. The sequences of these two primers were derived from within the
major ORF in BBTV DNA-4 (Burns et al.,
1995) and had no significant sequence
homology with any other DNA component of BBTV. However, to confirm that the
amplified products were derived from BBTV DNA-4, they were digested with Rsa I.
Sequence analysis of BBTV DNA-4 (Australian isolate; Burns et al., 1995), indicated
that Rsa I digestion of the expected PCR products from this component should result in
the generation of two fragments of 112 nts and 238 nts. When the PCR products were
digested with Rsa I and analysed, the two predicted restriction fragments were
observed from the PCR products from Australia, Fiji, India and Western Samoa
(Table 2). The 238 nt predicted fragment was
present in the
Rsa I digest of the Burundi isolate;
however the 112 nt product was not detected. Interestingly, PCR products from the
Taiwan and Philippines isolates were not digested with Rsa I and the PCR product from
the Vietnam isolate was only partially digested to yield a band of approximately 283 nt.
The primer pair BT129V3.17 and BT129C1.17 amplified the expected 355 bp product
from nucleic acid extracts of all isolates tested but did not amplify a product from
healthy banana extracts. The sequence of these two primers was derived from within
the major ORF in BBTV DNA-5 (Burns et al.,
1995). The second primer, BT129 C1.17,
was located 5' of the stem-loop sequence. Neither primer had significant sequence
homology with any other DNA component of BBTV. However, to confirm that the
amplified products were derived from BBTV DNA-5, they were digested with Rsa I.
Sequence analysis of BBTV DNA-5 (Australian isolate; Burns et al., 1995), indicated
that Rsa I digestion of the expected PCR products from this component should result in
the generation of two fragments of 129 nt and 226 nt. When the PCR products were
digested with Rsa I, the two predicted fragments were observed from the PCR products
from Australia, India, Fiji, Western Samoa and Burundi
(Table 2). In contrast, the Rsa
I
digested PCR product from Taiwan, Philippines and Vietnam isolates gave different
banding patterns. Fragments of approximately 166 nt and 141 nt were present in the
Taiwan and Philippines isolates, with the Taiwan isolate also containing a minor
fragment similar in size to the 226 nt band of the South Pacific group. The Vietnam
PCR product was not digested with Rsa I.
BBTV DNA-6

Two adjacent, outwardly extending primers, BTP2F1.17 and BTP2R1.17, derived from
within the major ORF of BBTV DNA-6 (Burns et
al., 1995) were used to amplify an
apparent full component length product from nucleic acid extracts of all BBTV isolates
tested but not from nucleic acid extracts from healthy bananas. Again, these products
were digested with Rsa I and analysed. Sequence analysis of BBTV DNA-6 (Australian
isolate; Burns et al., 1995), indicated
that Rsa I digestion of the expected PCR
products
from this component should result in the generation of eight fragments of 9 nt, 45 nt, 59
nt, 114 nt, 126 nt, 136 nt, 181 nt and 419 nt. Sequence analysis of BBTV DNA-6 from
Burundi and Fiji indicated that Rsa I digestion of the PCR products from these
components would result in the generation of 416 nt (Burundi), 419 nt (Fiji), 181 nt
(both), 136 nt (both), 126 nt (both), 114 nt (both), 104 nt (Fiji), 59 nt (Burundi), 45 nt
(Burundi) and 9 nt (both) fragments. Sequence analysis of BBTV DNA-6 from Western
Samoa indicated that Rsa I digestion of the PCR product from this component would
result in the generation of a 420 nt, 316 nt, 126 nt, 123 nt and 104 nt fragments.
The 181 nt and approximately 419 nt fragments were present in the Rsa I digested
PCR product from Australia, Burundi, Fiji and India. The Rsa I digested PCR product
from Western Samoa contained no 181 nt fragment but, in addition to a 419 nt
fragment, a band of approximately 316 nt that was not detected in any other isolate.
Multiple fragments ranging from 95 to 136 nt were observed in the Rsa I digest of each
PCR product but were not in sufficient concentration to allow a reliable comparison.
The restriction pattern of the Rsa I digested PCR products from the Asian isolates was
very different to that of the South Pacific group. The digested PCR products from
Taiwan, the Philippines and Vietnam all contained a fragment of approximately 870 nt,
which was not found in the digested PCR products of the South Pacific group.
Sequence analysis of BBTV DNA-6 from Taiwan and Vietnam indicated that Rsa I
digestion of the expected PCR products from these components should result in the
generation of 9 nt (Taiwan), 45 nt (both), 59 nt (both), 114 nt (both), 126 nt (Taiwan),
135 nt (Vietnam), 351 nt (Vietnam), 374 nt (Vietnam) and 730 nt (Taiwan) fragments. In
some cases the PCR products appeared only partially digested. This would explain the
differences between the expected range of Rsa I digest fragments and those obtained
and may have been due to (i) inefficient cleavage by the enzyme or (ii) a DNA sub-population
that lacked Rsa I restriction sites.
|

 Figure 3
 Figure 4
|

The apparent full component length amplified products from the Burundi, Fiji, Taiwan,
Vietnam and Western Samoa isolates were cloned into pGEM-T and sequenced in both
directions. These sequences were aligned with BBTV DNA-6 from an Australian isolate
(Burns et al., 1995) and compared
(Figure 3, Table 3). The sequences
varied in length
from 1078 nts to 1089 nts but importantly all contained a potential stem-loop structure,
the CR-SL, the CR-M, a potential TATA box, one major ORF in the virion sense and
one or two potential polyadenylation signals. All these sequences had been previously
identified in other BBTV components as well as BBTV DNA-6
(Burns et al., 1995;
Harding et al., 1993). When the BBTV DNA-6
sequences from all six isolates were
compared, two groups of isolates were evident, the South Pacific group (Australia,
Burundi, Fiji and Western Samoa) and the Asian group (Taiwan and Vietnam) (Figure 4).
The mean difference over the full component sequence was 3.2% within the South
Pacific group, 9.9% within the Asian group and 14.5% between the two groups
(Table 3;
Figure 4). The major ORF was highly conserved
within the South
Pacific group both at the
nucleotide and amino acid level; however, the difference between the ORF sequences
of the two Asian isolates was nearly as great as the difference between the two groups
of isolates (Table 3; Figure 4).
|

DISCUSSION
|


We have previously demonstrated that BBTV DNA-1, which encodes a putative Rep,
was associated with all BBTV isolates tested from 10 countries. Interestingly, when the
sequences of BBTV DNA-1 from these different isolates were compared, it was evident
that there were two groups of isolates, the South Pacific group and the Asian group
(Karan et al., 1994). We have now
demonstrated using either component specific PCR
primers or DNA probes that BBTV DNA-2, 3, 4, 5 and 6 were also present in all isolates
tested from seven countries (Table 4) and
therefore it is
probable that BBTV DNA-1 to 6
are all essential components of the BBTV genome. However, it is not possible to predict
whether BBTV requires only the Rep encoded by BBTV DNA-1 or one or more of the
additional Reps for replication.
There was obvious variation within the individual component sequences between
different isolates. For instance, none of the BBTV DNA-2 or 3 specific primer pairs
designed from the Australian isolate amplified those components from the Asian
isolates. The restriction fragment length polymorphism patterns generated by the
digestion of the BBTV DNA-4, 5 and 6 PCR products confirmed earlier evidence that
there were two groups of BBTV isolates. The RFLP patterns of the isolates from
Australia, Burundi, Fiji, India and Western Samoa were almost identical
(Table 2) and
these five isolates had previously been included in the South Pacific group based on
the sequence of their BBTV DNA-1 (Karan et al.,
1994). However, the RFLP patterns
for the three Asian isolates (the Asian group) were more similar to each other than they
were to those of the South Pacific group of isolates and within these isolates, the
Philippines and Taiwan isolates were more similar to each other than they were to the
Vietnam isolate (Table 2). These results
confirm the
previously determined relationship
of these three isolates to each other and the South Pacific group of isolates based on
the sequences of their BBTV DNA-1 where the Philippines and Taiwan isolates were
more closely related to one another than they were to the Vietnam isolate and all three
were more closely related to one another than they were to the South Pacific group of
isolates (Karan et al., 1994).
|

 Figure 3
|

The comparisons of the full sequences of BBTV DNA-6 from six isolates again
confirmed the division of BBTV isolates into the two groups (Figure 3,
Table 3). There was
greater variability within BBTV DNA-6 compared with BBTV DNA-1 between the two
Asian isolates and between the two groups whereas within the South Pacific group of
isolates, the CR-M and the ORF were more strongly conserved than the equivalent
regions within BBTV DNA-1 (Table 3). The
CR-M appears
to be an important marker for
the division of the two groups as it is strongly conserved within groups of isolates both
within and between components but there is between 27% and 32% sequence
difference between the two groups of isolates.
These results suggest that, while the Asian isolates are clearly more closely related to
each other than they are to the South Pacific group of isolates, they have undergone
considerably more divergence than the South Pacific group. This phenomenon could
reflect either the period of time in which these isolates have been evolving in bananas
in the Asian region or that there has been more than one introduction of BBTV into
bananas in the south east Asian region. The South Pacific group of isolates probably
have a much more recent common progenitor strengthening the probability that the
movement of BBTV through the South Pacific, Australia, South Asia and Africa has
been recent and derived from a single source.
It is now important to determine whether the other Rep encoding components identified
from Taiwanese isolates (Yeh et al., 1994;
Wu et al., 1994) are present in all
isolates of
BBTV and to develop an infectivity assay for BBTV to enable the identification of the
essential components of the BBTV genome.

|