Oilseed rape (OSR) is one of the most important arable crops worldwide, producing 12% of the world’s vegetable oil. It is a valuable crop used for both human and animal feed, in industrial processes for biofuel and lubricants, and as a break crop, highlighting its broad importance. Phoma stem canker is a disease caused by two pathogens: Leptosphaeria maculans (Lm) and L. biglobosa (Lb). In the early 2000s, a new subclade belonging to L. biglobosa was first identified in Canada, from which it derives its name ‘canadensis’ (Lbc). There has been a spread of this subclade globally, with isolates identified in Australia (2008), China (2021) and most recently at two sites in the UK (2022). Studies have suggested that the Lbc could be more damaging than other Lb subclades (e.g., Lb ‘brassicae’ (Lbb)).
The main aims of this project were to examine the pathogenicity of L. biglobosa ‘canadensis’ (Lbc) and to assess its growth response to different temperatures in order to investigate potential effects of climate change. Objective 1 explored the effect of temperature on mycelial growth of Lm, Lbb and Lbc isolates. Previous studies have shown that temperature influences host resistance to Lm, however, there is currently no information on how temperature affects resistance to Lb isolates. Agar plugs were inoculated onto fresh PDA plates and incubated for 14 days at 3 temperatures (20, 25 and 30°C). The 20°C was chosen as this was thought to be the preferred growing temperature for Lm and Lb isolates, with 25°C and 30°C chosen to mimic the effects of climate change. Radial mycelial growth measurements were taken daily for 12 days. Results showed all isolates exhibited maximum growth at 25°C and exhibited the least growth at 30°C. Post hoc pairwise comparisons indicated that Lbc isolate responded significantly differently in growth across temperatures compared to Lbb at 30°C and Lm at 20°C. Analyses also showed that Lm showed significant preference for growth at 25°C over 20°C (p=0.0103). Lm is considered to be the more damaging species due to its ability to form stem base cankers which cause lodging, leading to significant yield loss. Lm typically has slower growth compared to Lbb and Lbc but is more aggressive due to sirodesmin-PL production. These findings highlight potential risks under projected climate warming, since the optimal growth of Lm occurs at 25°C and higher temperatures may enhance its growth and pathogenicity.
Objective 2 investigated the pathogenicity of new Lbc isolates, comparing with existing Lm and Lbb isolates. Seedlings of OSR cultivars Drakkar (susceptible) and Barbados (resistant) were inoculated with conidial suspensions. Disease severity was assessed at 14 days post inoculation (dpi) by scoring leaf lesions on a 0-9 scale. Statistical analysis showed a significant difference between isolates (p<0.001) and a significant interaction between cultivar and isolate (p<0.001). Post hoc analysis revealed that in the resistant cultivar Barbados, isolate Lbc (1-2) induced significantly higher lesion severity compared to Lbb, suggesting greater pathogenicity of Lbc (1-2) isolate. In the susceptible cultivar Drakkar, there were no significant differences between isolates, likely due to a uniformly high lesion severity. These results provide preliminary evidence that Lbc isolates may have the potential to cause greater disease severity than Lm and Lbb isolates. These results warrant further investigation on the risk of severe phoma stem canker epidemics caused by the newly emerged Lbc subclades in the UK.
Throughout this project I have developed and learnt many skills relevant to my intended career pathway of plant pathology and crop protection. I would like to thank Professor Huang and the other lab members at University of Hertfordshire for their support and training during this project. I am very grateful to the BSPP for giving me the opportunity to work on this project.
Daisy Garratt
Durham University
9. BSPP_FinalReport_DGarratt – EDITED.docx-EmbeddedFile: a) Average radial mycelial growth (mm) of Leptosphaeria isolates at 20, 25, 30°C (n= 4 plates per isolate), i) Isolate growth at 20°C for harvesting conidia, b) Lesion severity score for Leptosphaeria isolates in resistant (Barbados) and susceptible (Drakkar) cultivars assessed at 14dpi (n=10-12 per isolate per cultivar), red oval indicates isolate with the potential to overcome resistance, ii) Left to right: Lbc (1-2) leaf lesion, inoculated cotyledons in trays, conducting disease assessment.


